Extremely popular podcaster Joe Rogan is just asking questions. Wrong questions, and many of them are frightening — especially when it comes to the coronavirus epidemic. He has discouraged young people Being vaccinatedPropagated theory is that the use of ivermectin in the treatment of unsupported covid is not widespread Protecting vaccine profits, And invited well-known Bad artists Arbitrarily spreading misinformation about vaccines.
There are such lacquers Millions The number of monthly downloads on Joe Rogan Experience (JRE), which makes him the biggest vehicle for lectures, is sympathetic to the antivax movement and sometimes actively promoting it. And its distributor, Spotify, is obviously willing to look for other ways to protect them Exclusive $ 100 million deal With him, even if that means letting him propagate wild conspiracy theories — as he did last month. In episode # 1757 of the JRE, Rogan invited a virologist named Dr. Robert Malone to inform the audience that the public health response to coronavirus, especially mass vaccination, was intimately linked to something called “mass formation psychosis”.
Malone’s credibility is largely based on his claim to have invented the mRNA vaccine. Whether it is true or not – The Atlantic reported He is one of the many scientists who have published important work on MRNA. Anti-wax movement. Malone claims not to be a vaccine skeptic, but questions Safety and effectiveness The actual mRNA vaccine on the market. Many demands have been made on him Rated as false By fact-checkers and Many other scientists More or less he suggested he had gone off the rails. In Malone’s words, the mentality of mass formation is exactly the same as it was before the rise of the Third Reich of the Nazi Party in Germany, when the massesLiterally becomes hypnotized And it can be led anywhere. “Malone told Rogan that this is why members of the public believe and respond to the so-called extreme, omnipresent response to social pressure to get vaccinated.
In reality, mass formation is psychosis It’s not A Valid scientific concept And, according to experts in fields like crowd and social psychology, it has no credibility. (According to the AP, John Dury, a social psychologist at the University of Sussex, and Steven J. Lin, a professor of psychology at the University of Binghamton, have developed this theory based on the disrespectful notion surrounding the psyche and the power of hypnosis.) Is Right-wing and anti-Waxers benefit culture-war-shake-up public health system who just want to re-brand what is happening Wrong Label it as an enviable possession of forbidden knowledge and anyone who disagrees as a mentally ill sheep. This is the main reason why the Malone episode went viral.
That was too much for YouTube, which took a clip of Malone’s interview under its Covid-19 misinformation policy. For its part, Spotify has done Jack Shit. Rolling Stone reported About 270 scientists, medical professionals and science educators led by Jessica Malati Rivera, an infectious disease epidemiologist at Boston Children’s Hospital, signed on Wednesday. An open letter to Spotify Malone featured and denounced Rogan for spreading other deceptive claims about Covid and the vaccine. They are not claiming that Spotify will omit Rogan or delete the episode, but simply create a defined policy on misinformation. From the letter:
On December 31, 2021, Joe Rogan Experience (JRE), a Spotify-exclusive podcast, uploaded a highly controversial episode featuring guests. Dr. Robert Malone (# 1757). Episode done Criticized There is an issue for propagating baseless conspiracy theories and JRE History For the transmission of false information, especially regarding the COVID-19 epidemic. By allowing false and socially harmful statements to spread, Spotify is enabling its hosted media to undermine public confidence in scientific research and sow the seeds of doubt in the credibility of data-driven guidelines provided by medical professionals.
… with an estimated 11 million listeners per episode, JRE is the largest podcast in the world and has tremendous impact. Although Spotify’s platform has a responsibility to reduce the spread of misinformation, the company does not currently have a misinformation policy.
The letter noted that the average age of Rogan’s audience was 24, and those between 12 and 34 years who did not receive the vaccine were: 12 times as possible Those who have been vaccinated must be hospitalized. The signatories noted that they would be tasked with “repairing the damaged public understanding of science and medicine” and “the weight of an epidemic that has pushed our medical system beyond their limits.” The letter concludes that allowing Rogan to spread misleading nonsense is not only a scientific or medical problem, but also a “sociological problem of devastating proportions”.
“These are marginal ideas that are not supported by science, and being on a huge platform, it seems like there are two sides to the problem,” Katin Wallace, an epidemiologist at the University of Illinois Chicago School of Public Health, told Rolling Stone. “And really not. The overwhelming proof is that the vaccine works and it’s safe.”
Spotify does not seem to have a solid misinformation policy in its current form বিপর unlike many other large platforms, which are at least on paper, even if they are poorly enforced. It would be a trick to introduce such a policy and ask Rogan to hold on to it in the future, if only Spotify neglected to port 42 JRE episodes when signing a contract with Rogan in 2020 alone. According to diversityThese editions include Milo Yanopoulos, the racist instigator, Gavin McInes, the founder of the Fascist Street-Fighting Proud Boys Group, the infamous troll, and Accused Holocaust denier Charles C. Johnson, the anti-woman Carl “Sargon of Akkad” Benjamin, and Wayne Benjamin, a comedian best known for his anti-Semitism. The decision to throw those episodes into the memory hole doesn’t seem to set a precedent.
Rogan later said that not porting the episodes, which angered his fans enough, was part of the $ 100 million deal: “There were some episodes they didn’t want on their platform and I ‘okay’, I don’t care.‘“But he Insisted From which point there would be no corporate intervention: “Like many people, ‘they are telling Joe Rogan what he can and cannot do.’ They are not – they are not. ”
Again, Rogan has an estimated 11 million listeners per episode. To put it bluntly, primetime around Tucker Carlson is simply the king of news 3 million Viewers in each episode. It’s safe to say that if Spotify did anything about the Malone episode, they would risk losing one of their biggest cash-cow investments. Spotify probably doesn’t even want a chance to annoy fans who use their platform several times a week, let alone the inevitable firestorm of conservatives eager to make him their latest poster boy for censorship.
It’s called Spotify sporadically Of the media That last year It is Removes antivax content This is because it prohibits “content on the platform that promotes dangerous false, deceptive or misleading content about Covid-19 that may cause harm offline and / or pose a direct threat to public health”. So obviously some kind of policy exists, at least to the extent that they can get it out arbitrarily. Spotify is not clear about the specifics of that rule or how they apply it. The only thing that is clear is that Rogan is apparently immune to it.
Spotify did not respond to Gizmodo’s request for comment. Tao did not respond CNBC, Mountains, The The Washington Post, Deadline, Fate, Or New York Daily News, Among other publications. Why would they? They don’t give a shit. Go ahead and prove us wrong.
“Content is being spread considering their role in society, and there is a responsibility not to exacerbate the problem in a global public health emergency,” Rivera told Rolling Stone, the letter’s organizer. “It simply came to our notice then. These are preventable diseases for which people like Joe Rogan and Dr. Robert Malone are directly responsible. ”